New US tariffs on steel and aluminium imports are threatening thousands of jobs and putting pressure on the already struggling steel industry, reports 20 minutes. Swiss exports to the USA are particularly affected, as low margins make trade unattractive. There is also growing concern that a trade war with the EU could further exacerbate the economic situation. We have again taken a look at the opinions of our readers.
US tariffs on steel and aluminum imports - Comment Analysis/Methodology
How can you use comment analytics?
Comment analyses can provide PR and communications managers with arguments and sentiments around hot topics. They help to understand positions, classify them better and develop potential improvement measures or communication approaches. With this in mind, we have clustered and summarized the article's comments into 20 minutes. They represent the opinions of web visitors on the topic of US tariffs on steel and aluminum, which we examine with the help of our comment analysis.
US tariffs on steel and aluminum imports - What readers think
We have summarized and grouped the comments under the 20 minutes article on US tariffs on steel and aluminium as part of our comment analysis.
1. Political polarization around Trump and trade policy: Many comments revolve around Donald Trump and his economic policy. While some praise him for his protectionist stance and see his tariffs as a necessary measure against economic imbalances, others criticize him sharply and see the trade conflicts as short-sighted and damaging to the global economy.
2. Criticism of energy policy and its impact on industry: Several comments argue that not only tariffs, but above all high energy prices are endangering the European steel industry. Some call for a move away from climate protection measures and a greater focus on cheap energy sources, while others emphasize that sustainable energies are now more efficient.
3. Demands for economic independence: Some commentators advocate for production to be relocated back to Europe or Switzerland, while others call for a stronger economic alliance with Russia or the BRICS states as an alternative to the EU.
4. Doubts about the need for the steel industry in Switzerland: Some voices question whether Switzerland needs a steel industry at all, arguing that energy should be used for more important sectors.
5. Scepticism about the long-term costs of trade conflicts: Some commentators point to the administrative costs and negative impacts of trade tariffs, citing examples such as Brexit, which continues to cause economic chaos.
Threatened Steel Industry - Political Options for Action
1. Short-term stabilization measuresWhat measures are available to Switzerland to counter US policy? 1.1. Negotiations on trade tariffs Bilateral agreement with the USA: Direct negotiations on an exemption for Swiss steel products to reduce the negative impact of US tariffs. EU vote on a common strategy: A coordinated response to US tariffs by EU and EFTA partners could create stronger negotiating positions. 1.2. Reducing energy and production costs Subsidies or tax breaks for energy-intensive industries to make the location more competitive. Better incentives for investments in renewable energies that enable cheaper electricity prices in the long term. 1.3. Direct financial support Transitional funds for steel companies to offset short-term losses and secure jobs. Research funding for climate-friendly steel production to receive long-term funding from international partners (EU, Switzerland). 2. Long-term strategies for maintaining the location In addition to the immediate measures, long-term decisions must be made to ensure the long-term competitiveness of the Swiss steel industry. 2.1. Technological innovation and "green steel" Promotion of low-CO₂ production processes such as hydrogen-based steel production (e.g. H2Green Steel in Europe). Collaboration with research institutions such as ETH Zurich to develop energy-efficient processes. Access to international funding programs for sustainable industrial production to make Swiss steel fit for the future. 2.2. Economic diversification and location promotion Stronger integration into global supply chains to reduce dependence on individual markets such as the USA. Incentives for companies to concentrate in cluster regions in order to exploit synergies with other industrial sectors. 2.3. Political integration and trade policy Strengthening cooperation with the EU (e.g. maintaining advantageous trade relations through bilateral agreements). Diversification of export markets by having Swiss steel producers cooperate more closely with Asian and South American markets. Recommendation Combination of short-term adjustments and long-term transformation Short term: A combination of tariff negotiations, targeted support and energy cost reductions is necessary to protect the steel industry from immediate closures. Long term: A clear focus on sustainable steel production ("green steel") and international networking is crucial to keeping the industry in Switzerland in the long term. |
Comment Analysis - Advanced Evaluation Methods
Communication Metrics
We not only measure how many comments and replies were posted, but also do further calculations to understand the nature of communication and derive instructions for action.
Polarization
Our degree of polarization reflects the extent of polarization in opinions. The more the bars dominate on the left or right, the more pronounced the field of opinion is. As we can see from the example of "US tariffs on steel and aluminum threaten Swiss jobs," polarization is extensive in both directions of the opinion spectrum.
Network
n
With the help of the network representation, it is possible to make statements about communication types and their interaction.
Shown are "nodes", the small points that represent acting people, and "edges", which are the connecting lines between actors or with themselves.
We also differentiate between centralized (the master account determines communication) and decentralized communication styles. In the example on the left, separate discussion groups are formed independently of the author of the post.
As we can see from the example of the discussion about "US tariffs on steel and aluminum", the discussion is essentially very intense, with few "broadcasters" in the area.